Considered and rejected
What didn’t make the list, and why.
Lullaby Gloworm (Blue) · Playskool
Not available — could not be verified in stock new from a reputable US retailer (secondhand and out-of-stock listings only); and no maker or retailer US compliance claim found for this item (catalog data lists CE only).
Internal review – no submission link on file
Rejected October 25, 2026.
Silicone Train Toy · Siliconemania
No compliance claim — the product page names no toy safety standard (no CPSIA, ASTM F963, or EN71), only material claims (food-grade silicone, BPA-free).
https://www.siliconemania.com/products/silicone-train-toy
Rejected October 25, 2026.
Pikler Triangle Set 4-in-1 (331-066V01MX) · Qaba
Not available — could not be verified in stock from a reputable retailer; suspected no longer manufactured.
Internal review – no submission link on file
Rejected October 24, 2026.
Baby Tummy Time Gallery · Wee Gallery
Recall — 2024 joint CPSC/Health Canada recall (DEHP over limits). Do not list.
Internal review – no submission link on file
Rejected October 23, 2026.
The same bar that puts a toy on the list keeps one off it. A rejection here is a decision with a reason, not a quiet omission, and nothing in flight appears here: held items stay off this page until they are decided.
Have a toy to suggest? Suggest a toy
How this page stays current. A suggestion or an internal candidate goes to editors for review. When editors reject it, the entry appears here automatically from the review record, with its original submission link (where one exists) and the reason. Nothing publishes here straight from a suggestion form. If a rejection is later overturned, the entry stays on the record marked as overturned instead of being deleted.