How we decide what gets listed
What we check before a toy earns a place on the list.
Before any toy is graded, it has to pass nine checks, in this order. A toy that fails any one of them does not get listed, even if everything else looks good:
- Is it a toy for a baby to play with? We list toys a baby actually plays with, not gear a baby is placed in, carried in, or lies on. True books, anything with an ISBN, are out.
- Is it something we never list? Some things are never listed, no matter what their paperwork says: seated or wheeled baby walkers, doorway jumpers, and Bumbo-style floor seats. Push walkers are different, and they go through the normal checks. See what we never list.
- Does the age fit? Every toy has a youngest age it is made for. To show up in an age group, that youngest age has to fall inside that group. A toy that fits no group still appears on All toys and on its brand page, just not in an age group.
- What proof is there for this exact toy? We grade the paperwork, not the marketing. Documented means we found a public document for this exact toy. Program-backed means the maker describes a testing program. Compliance-stated means all we have is a claim that it complies. If we cannot find proof at any of those levels, the toy does not get listed, and a suggestion is not listed on a say-so alone. See how grading works.
- Has it been recalled? We check current recall status before listing. If a warning applies to a whole brand, it lives on the brand page, not hidden on one product page.
- Are we sure which exact toy this is? We pin down the exact item, by its UPC and model number, before we check whether you can buy it. That way the paperwork, photo, and buy link all belong to the same toy.
- Can you actually buy it? It has to be in stock, available across the US from a reputable retailer, with a photo, price, and buy link we have checked ourselves and rechecked at listing time.
- Does its brand have a page? If it is a new brand, we write a brand page about the brand itself, not about one product. The details for each toy stay on that toy’s page.
- Did we ask for missing paperwork, and keep it honest? Where paperwork is not public, we ask the brand to publish it first. We only host a document with permission. If a brand says no, we do not host it and we do not count it. And if we asked, that request stays visible on the listing, whether or not the brand ever replies.
Two more rules keep this a curated list, not just a filtered catalog. First, one card per toy: the same toy in a different color, or with a different character on it, is still one card, not several. Second, no single brand ever takes over an age group. If we ever make an exception, we write it down. Exceptions do not quietly become new rules.
This page follows our Listing Handbook, version 1.0. When the handbook changes, this page changes with it.